Suggest a product

The product archive.

Earlier readings, with the corrections kept close.

All current calls are withdrawn. The archive keeps the corrections and sources visible; it supplies no current product recommendation. Read the useful questions and source readings.

Compare archived formulas →Suggest another look →
Browse categories

14 records shown

Glycolic Acid 7% Exfoliating TonerThe Ordinary · exfoliation/activesWe withdrew this call. Our earlier call overstated regulatory support and used an incorrect ingredient order.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → MINI+ Facial Toning DeviceNuFACE · tools/devicesWe withdrew this call. Our earlier device comparison relied on unrelated guidance and an unsupported consumable-cost claim.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Creme de la MerLa Mer · moisturizerWe withdrew this call. Our earlier ingredient and pH analysis does not match the current source, and the substitute claim was not established.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Beauty ElixirCaudalie · facial mist / toner / essenceWe withdrew this call. Our earlier formula analysis invented concentrations and missed ingredients in the current brand list.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → SOS Daily Rescue Facial SprayTower 28 · mist / tonerWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → AHA 30% + BHA 2% Peeling SolutionThe Ordinary · exfoliation/activesWe withdrew this call. Our earlier call dismissed formula-related risk without adequate support.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40Supergoop · facial sunscreenWe withdrew this call. Our earlier call needs an exact variant and a supported comparison before it can guide a purchase.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Acne Foaming Wash 10% Benzoyl PeroxidePanOxyl · cleanser / acne activeWe withdrew this call. Our earlier call omitted available label information and overstated the recommendation supported by it.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Watermelon Glow Niacinamide Dew DropsGlow Recipe · serum / highlighting skincare hybridWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → D-Bronzi Bronzing Drops with PeptidesDrunk Elephant · serum / makeup-skincare hybridWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → DRx SpectraLite FaceWare Pro 3-Minute LED DeviceDr. Dennis Gross · tools/devicesWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Brazilian Bum Bum CreamSol de Janeiro · body moisturizerWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Peptide Glazing Fluidrhode · serum / essenceWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction → Advanced Snail 96 Mucin Power EssenceCOSRX · essence / serumWe withdrew this call after finding misidentified source material. The earlier recommendation is not a current buying recommendation.CALL WITHDRAWNRead correction →